
Directed by Joel Coen & Ethan Coen
Written by Joel Coen & Ethan Coen
2004 | 104 minutes | English
DVD
Tom Hanks, Irma P. Hall, Marlon Wayans, J.K. Simmons, Tzi Ma, Ryan Hurst, Diane Delano, George Wallace, Stephen Root, Jason Weaver, Greg Grunberg, Bruce Campbell
What it’s about: Mrs. Marva Munson (Hall) is a proper churchgoing Mississippi widow with a cat named Pickles and a room to rent in her house. That room is taken up by fast-talking “Professor” Goldthwaite Higginson Dorr, Ph.D. (Hanks). He claims to be on sabbatical from a university to lead a renaissance musical ensemble, but in truth, his aim is to dig a tunnel from Mrs. Munson’s cellar to reach and rob the nearby underground vault of a local casino, and his so-called bandmates are, in fact, a motley group of criminals. There’s the booty-loving hoodrat and inside man, Gawain MacSam (Wayans), the IBS-afflicted munitions expert, Garth Pancake (Simmons), the reticent tunneling expert known as The General (Ma), and the thickheaded muscle, Lump Hudson (Hurst). Pulling off the scheme will involve keeping the old lady fooled while they work, but internal tensions in the group and the hand of fate itself seem to be working against their efforts.
Reflections: A remake, in premise at least, of the 1955 Ealing comedy, and the only Coen Brothers movie I hadn’t seen before, this has a reputation for being one of their lesser efforts and it is, but it’s still an interestingly odd movie. The tendency of their characters toward eccentric mannerisms and stylized dialogue is dialed up to eleven here, exemplified most by Hanks giving one of the weirdest performances of his career–a hifalutin’ hornswoggler with a cruelly arrogant streak and an awkwardly swallowed laugh who never uses one word where ten will do. The other criminals come off like cartoonish sketches that lean into the broad, often very slapstick comedy. It’s only Hall’s Mrs. Munson that feels like she might have some basis in an actual human person, and her forceful presence does a lot to keep at least one of the movie’s feet on the ground.
The Mississippi setting infuses the film with thick drawls and plenty of rousing gospel music, but what’s being done with it isn’t entirely clear. There is some kind of commentary on race happening–Pancake lording that he was one of the Freedom Riders, Mrs. Munson’s admiration of Bob Jones University (which has a long and notable history of regressive racial policies), the exchange between Gawain and his casino boss Stephen Root about a discrimination lawsuit, and so on–but the message of it gets a little lost amidst the poop jokes and inconvenient explosions. And despite the silliness of it all, the absurd convenience of the crew’s fate after the heist feels in line with the deeply cynical streak of the Coens’ other films in the mid-to-late 2000s. There is something vaguely dark happening here, but it doesn’t completely land.
But there is also a lot to enjoy. The movie looks typically gorgeous, with cinematographer and frequent collaborator Roger Deakins bathing the proceedings in golden southern light. And many of the gags and lines are genuinely funny, peppered with sly wit and acted out by an excellent cast. Ultimately, even a more half-baked Coen Brothers film is still going to be pretty good and, even if this one feels stretched a little thin by the end, it’s still too bizarre to be boring.








