
Directed by Carl Reiner
Written by Phil Alden Robinson
1984 | 91 minutes | English
Fullscreen Format DVD
Steve Martin, Lily Tomlin, Victoria Tennant, Madolyn Smith, Richard Libertini, Dana Elcar, Jason Bernard, Gailard Sartain, Selma Diamond, Eric Christmas
What it’s about: Roger Cobb (Martin) just turned 38, and even though he’d rather be playing jazz with his friend Tyrone (Bernard), it’s time to buckle down and get serious. His boss at the law firm, Burton Schuyler (Elcar)–who also happens to be his girlfriend Peggy’s (Smith) dad–takes notice and promises to put him on more important cases, including both his own divorce and seeing to the vast estate of sheltered heiress Edwina Cutler (Tomlin). After a life of being in a sickbed, she’s finally dying but has leveraged her wealth to enlist the eccentric Tibetan mystic Prahka Lasa (Libertini) to transfer her soul upon death into the body of the young and beautiful Terry Hoskins (Tennant) for a second chance at life. Roger reasonably thinks she’s bonkers, and isn’t shy about saying so, but it’s legit. Except, by accident, her soul ends up in his body instead, leaving her able to speak through his mouth and control his right side. And as they are forced to cooperate to rectify the situation, all manner of hijinks ensue.
Reflections: This was a first time watch of a movie I inherited from an old living situation, so I wasn’t sure what to expect, and I was struck by how charming it feels. It’s high-concept, but in a way that doesn’t feel engineered to make a point–it’s a wacky adventure with some broad moral lessons that’s a chance to allow its charming leads to shine. And they do. Tomlin is in the background for most of the movie–appearing in mirrors and providing voiced-over thoughts, but giving just the right amount of sauce to her naive, uptight, entitled but lonely rich girl. And Martin is doing some amazing physical work–his two halves battling it out or switching full control on the fly–while giving off a slightly acidic, beleaguered everyman appeal.
Beyond the comic star-power of the leads, there’s kind of an anything-goes ’80s vibe going on, for better and for worse. Casting Richard Libertini as a stereotypical Asian swami is… a choice that doesn’t exactly hold up, but he does play the character with a kind of knowing indifference–the joke feels like it isn’t that Prakha doesn’t know how to use a telephone, it’s that he simply doesn’t care to–that at least helps. There’s some sexual humor that doesn’t quite land as smoothly as the rest of it. And it hardly feels like a spoiler to point out one shouldn’t trust a British accent in an ’80s American comedy but Victoria Tennant does both the spaced-out hippie and the conniving schemer well enough.
This isn’t a movie I would call a laugh riot, exactly–unless incredulously shouting “I’m talking to a bucket!” really gets you. Nor is it aesthetically daring or richly textured, particularly–the mirror effect is the most interesting bit of the filmmaking. It all feels sort of quaint, but in a way that’s relaxed and warm. It feels totally appropriate that I just kind of wound up with it because someone I lived with remembered it from childhood–like something handed down from someone cool from my mother’s generation. And it’s pretty short, just WTF enough to stay interesting as a story, and an excuse to watch Steve Martin and Lily Tomlin together, which is a good time.








