
Directed by Nunnally Johnson
Written by Nunnally Johnson
1957 | 91 minutes | English
DVD
Joanne Woodward, David Wayne, Lee J. Cobb, Edwin Jerome, Alena Murray, Nancy Kulp, Douglas Spencer, Terry Ann Ross, Ken Scott, Mimi Gibson, Alistair Cooke
What it’s about: Based, loosely and somewhat controversially, on the true-life case of Christine Costner Sizemore, this follows a woman, initially known as Eve White (Woodward), who comes with her husband Ralph (Wayne) to receive psychiatric treatment from Dr. Curtis Luther (Cobb) in the summer of 1951. The meek and dreary young mother has been experiencing blackouts and, when she has one in Dr. Luther’s office and transforms into a childish and forward party girl calling herself Eve Black, it is soon established that she has a rare case of what was then known as multiple personality disorder. She enters treatment with the doctor but the disruptions become more serious, putting a strain on her marriage, isolating her from her daughter, and preventing either side of her from living a full life. As the Eves become more desperate, a third identity emerges, giving Dr. Luther hope for a chance at uniting all her personalities back into a core self.
Reflections: This was another first-time watch for me, of a DVD I acquired a few years ago, going through my aunt’s collection and finding duplicates. And there are some aspects of this movie–how psychological and cultural understanding of DID has evolved, how the real person felt about the film and its effect on her–that are worth discussing in another context. But looking at it as a piece of classic film and setting aside the narrator (Cooke) and the salesman’s enthusiasm of his introduction, it remains a pretty compelling combination of character study and mystery. One that hinges on its central performance, so what feels most significant here is Joanne Woodward knocking it out of the park and winning her Oscar.
Early on, the switch between Eves comes off a little like a party trick–the distinction between them is almost cartoonish and the little nod she falls into as one or the other comes out seems contrived. But what Woodward, and by extension the film, succeeds at is slowly opening each side of the character as the story expands. As Eve White comes to understand the situation and what it’s costing her, the timid Mrs. So-and-So that first appears becomes something darker and more individual; as Eve Black is forced to appreciate the dependence she has on her other half and the seriousness of her predicament, she becomes cleverer, more honest, and more vulnerable. And when the third personality appears, it is evident before she even speaks, simply from the subtlety of the actress’s posture. She takes the audience on the same journey as the doctors in the story: from distrust and incredulity, to a kind of technical amazement, to a real sympathy. It’s stunning to watch.
The rest of the film mostly stays out of her way. Cobb gives off a (relatively) sympathetic wit, meeting Woodward as the relationship between the doctor and each personality evolves. Wayne captures a man reacting with anger to something he can’t wrap his head around. And Johnson isn’t doing anything especially stylistic (aside from one interesting touch toward the end, where Woodward is shrunk to child-size as part of a memory). His script–written with the input of the actual doctors on the case–does sand down a lot of the details and falls firmly into the 1950s starry-eyed melodramatic tradition, despite the utter verisimilitude with which it advertises itself. But taken in that frame of reference, it’s a good one, and the magnetism of the lead performance is worth the price of admission alone.








